You know we all speculate on whether Greg Halman could be a big leaguer. Can he grow anymore as a professional hitter?
My question is does he have to grow anymore? Sure, he still isn’t polished and he won’t have anything on Mark Reynolds. But, is it possible that all he has to do is sit on fastballs?
Despite all the known scouting reports on Halman he still saw fastballs at a 48% rate according to fangraphs. That is nearly half the pitches he saw were fastballs. Sure he is going to get beat on some off speed pitches. But why not just play completely off his strengths.
According to fangraphs, Josh Hamilton received the lowest percentage of fastballs (46%) thrown during a plate appearance among qualified hitters (and remains the leader amongst hitters with at least 200 PA’s) in 2010. Who’s to say that Halman would receive anything less than 45%?
Halman has epic power and sticking him in the middle of the line-up with a regressed Figgins and Ichiro still doing his thing screams fastballs.
Sure, the guy doesn’t do well with bendy stuff and will have a perpetual problem during the most inopportune times. Sure, he is still going to strike out upwards of 35-40% of the time, if not more. But, is it possible that with that despite 40% of his at bats ending in strike outs he could still end up being valuable at the plate?
While hitting in Tacoma 22.4% of his fly balls went for home runs. Not to mention 58 of his 101 hits went for extra bases.
If we go back his minor league track record where he has a propensity to hit fly balls. He averages about 31.70% of all his hit balls are fly balls. If we assume that he still manages to put the ball in play at a 55-60% rate that would mean he would in the ball in the air roughly 19% of the time while at bat.
Taking his HR/FB ratio over his minor league career (16% by my calculation), he would hit a home run 3.04% of all plate appearances. Roughly 21 home runs over 700 at bats. Now obviously, home runs aren’t everything. But the point is simple. He could still maintain his power production at the big league level despite the strike outs.
I believe Halman can produce a meager wOBA of .330. Looking over his minor league career according to statcorner you see that even in his horrendous 2009 he still posted a wOBA of .311 in AA West Tennessee. Even if he only hits .240/.310/.450 his wOBA should be around .340 -.350 because of what else he is able to do on the field.
All this while we haven’t talked at all about his defensive tools. He is still a defensive plus in the corner and is average or better in center. Over the course of 350 at bats, or basically being a platoon player, that is worth roughly 1.5 WAR.
Consider Ryan Langerhans for a second. He’s a perfect comparison. Over 2 years as a Mariner he’s amounted 254 PA’s and a wOBA of roughly .309 while posting +10 UZR in the “outfield”. That’s good for 1.3 WAR. Everyone still loves Langerhans. Yet he’s struck out 79 times in 254 attempts. Still posting an ISO of .145. I think that’s a fair comparison. Halman may have more power, but the his problems with pitch recognition are going to keep his power from “grading” out nearly as high as it could.
Don’t miss understand me. I like Ryan Langerhans, but he is going to 31 years old by the time the season starts. That’s the wrong side of 30 in baseball. Greg Halman is only 23, not to mention a higher ceiling.
He is going to have some rough patches and adjusting to MLB pitching is not going to be pretty. But give him 1200 PA’s and I think he is a major leaguer now. That’s my opinion.
Now all that and I’m going to admit, I’m not sure there is room for him on the 25-man roster to start the season. But, based on the NRI’s we have coming into camp there really isn’t anyone that can consistently play a “good” center full-time outside of Gutirrez. Halman is a major league right fielder but I believe he could pass as a center fielder just as well as Ryan Langerhans could.
I’m not saying Ryan Langerhans should be cast a side or that he is no longer useful because he is 31. It might be better to start Halman off in Tacoma and use Ryan Langerhans at the big league level for a while. But, lets remember what this season is really about. Giving the young guys the opportunity to show us what they have.
What good is it really going to be for Halman to spend another 400+ PAs in Tacoma crushing fastballs, striking out another 150+ times and making us wonder if he could be of any use. Just give him some time this year. That’s all I’m saying.